Mark (generalist) wrote,

Tape storage may not be dead after all


Years ago (1995-1998) when I was at SGI, one of the main things I did was deal with digital storage tapes and robotic jukeboxes for same. I owned the technical relationship that SGI had with Legato (of NetWorker fame) at the time. Tape as a storage medium has been fading for quite a while; in fact, many have been saying the we should just use disks for everything and stop using tapes altogether.

Tape is undeniably slower to access, and the cost per bit stored of disk drive data has dropped precipitously in recent years, to almost reach the same per-bit cost of tape. Today's tape cost is $75/400Gb (uncompressed) = 18 3/4 cents per Gb of LTO3 tape. Today's hard drive cost is $205/400Gb = 51 1/4 cents per Gb of USB/FireWire removable hard drive. Of course, we also need a tape drive to read and write the tape (a little more than $2,200 today). The tape robot units we buy at my current company have 2 of these drives and 29 slots into which tapes can be put when not in use, all for about $21k apiece.

But this doesn't tell the whole story, at all:

  • Tapes are more durable than disks: they are vibration-resistant, can survive immersion in water and many other types of fluid, can often be read in part if the whole is not readable, have no electronics to break, have few moving parts, etc.
  • Even after the right tape is located and loaded into the tape drive, tapes are inherently sequential-access devices, whereas disks are, at least practically speaking, random-access devices.
  • Individual disks are faster than slow tapes. A relatively-fast FireWire attached single disk drive can read at 39 Mb/s. A large disk array can be read at full FiberChannel speeds of 350+ MB/s. A super-fast Ultrium-960 LTO3 tape drive can write at 124 Mb/s, according to this report.
The reason I bring this up today is that IBM recently announced a very real increase (~15x) in the storage density possible on a tape. I love technology.

Cheers! generalist

Tags: technology

  • Lost dreams

    Hi! [This posting was lost for a long time (many weeks), LJ restored it to me today] Dream 1 (from night before last): There was a killer on…

  • Context is everything

    Hi! I just today saw a product description use a completely different context than the typical one I use, for three words I use all of the…

  • Why you should jailbreak your iPhone

    Hi! You probably know you probably should've jail-broken your iPhone a long time ago, because there are plenty of non Apple approved apps that…

  • Post a new comment


    default userpic

    Your reply will be screened

    When you submit the form an invisible reCAPTCHA check will be performed.
    You must follow the Privacy Policy and Google Terms of use.
  • 1 comment